Renting vs. buying: How to make the right decision?

04 June 2024 by National Bank
Moving boxes illustration for an article about buying or renting a house

Not sure whether to buy or rent your next home? Follow the steps below to get all the tools you need to make the right decision.

Identify your ambitions and plans

For many people, buying a property is a life goal. It’s also often the biggest purchase they ever make. But because becoming a homeowner comes with many new responsibilities, it’s important not to take the plunge too quickly.

Thinking of buying a property? Start by asking yourself these questions about your situation:

  • Are you prepared for the upkeep, potential renovations, emergency work and unforeseen expenses associated with owning a property?
  • Is homeownership important to you?
  • If you’re buying as a couple, is your relationship solid enough?
  • Is your professional situation stable?

Consider what your plans are for the next five years. For example:

  • Do you want to have children?
  • Do you plan to move to another city or even another country?
  • Do you plan to stay in the same job in the long term?

Your answers to these questions are a good starting point to help you make the right choice.

Pictogramme d'une fusée

Take stock of your financial situation

Is buying a property the best option given your situation? If you decide that it is, make a budget to find out whether your current income (minus your expenses) is sufficient to absorb the cost of a property. Don’t forget to plan for a financial cushion to cover unexpected events.

Pictogramme ampoule qui s’allume

Good to know : The 50-20-30 rule is very useful for budgeting. This means allocating :

  • 50% of your net income for essential expenses (housing, food, electricity, etc.)
  • 20% for savings and debt repayment
  • 30% for non-essential expenses (leisure, sports, outings, travel, etc.)

Assess your borrowing capacity

The most realistic way to see if you can afford to buy a property is to estimate the mortgage amount you could obtain. You can use our simple tool to calculate your maximum loan amount.

When you take out a mortgage, financial institutions will typically calculate a higher mortgage rate than the one you’d actually be getting, which is known as the qualifying rate. This helps you determine whether you’ll be able to meet your mortgage payments if interest rates rise. 

Pictogramme ampoule qui s’allume

Pro tip : Let’s imagine that the monthly cost of the property you’re interested in is $1,800 a month and that you’re currently paying $1,300 a month in rent. To find out if you’d be able to pay that extra $500, you can start today by putting that amount aside each month. If you find this easy to do, you can rest assured that you have the capacity to make monthly mortgage payments of $1,800.

Consider all the costs involved in buying a home

Buying a property comes with many advantages. In a way, it’s a form of “forced savings” that helps you build your wealth. Owning your own home also gives you long-term stability as well as the freedom to decorate and renovate your home to suit your personal tastes.

However, this investment doesn’t come with guaranteed profits, and there can also be considerable financial and psychological burdens associated with maintaining a property. Here are the main costs to consider when making your decision. 

Costs to consider when buying

To purchase a property, you need to make a minimum down payment of 5% of its value. There are also other costs to consider, such as appraisal and inspection fees. Plus, you need to include the legal fees of the person (notary, lawyer) who will be handling the transaction.

If your down payment is less than 20%, you’ll need to purchase mortgage insurance. In Quebec, Ontario and Saskatchewan, you must also pay a provincial sales tax on the insurance premium. This amount cannot be added to your loan amount.

Buying a property in a new development? In this case, tax will be added to the final purchase price. On the other hand, should you opt for an older property, there may be additional costs related to renovations. In either case, you’ll need to factor in welcome or transfer taxes as well as moving expenses. 

→ Read our article on 9 fees to consider when buying a home

Annual property expenses

Being a homeowner comes at a cost: In addition to mortgage payments, you also have to cover several annual expenses, including municipal and school taxes and loan insurance. Buying a condominium? Don’t forget to factor in condo fees

Coping with the unexpected

Unplanned renovations or repairs? Rising municipal taxes or mortgage rates? When you’re a homeowner, you need to be prepared for the unexpected. That’s why it’s important to have an emergency fund in your budget.

Pictogramme ampoule qui s’allume

Save to build your wealth in other ways

Most experts agree that buying property isn’t for everyone. In addition to generally offering greater flexibility and peace of mind, renting an apartment can be a favourable option if your monthly rent is affordable. And depending on the amount of your down payment, the rent/space ratio is often more advantageous than the mortgage/space ratio.

That said, renting gives you less freedom. You’re dependent on your landlord’s availability and attentiveness when it comes to maintenance. You also need to find another way to build your wealth.  

And how do you build wealth as a tenant? The key is to be disciplined and save as much as possible. Saving helps you build financial value for the future so you can enjoy a comfortable retirement. 

Pictogramme d'une fusée

Still wondering whether you should buy or rent? Our calculator will help you determine whether or not it’s financially worthwhile for you. Take the test!

→ To watch de full episode: Buying or Renting? Important Questions to Ask

It’s important to remember that choosing to rent or buy isn’t only a question of money, it’s also a matter of lifestyle choices and emotional considerations. That’s why these factors need to be carefully weighed before making a decision.

Are you wondering whether or not you’re ready to buy a house?

 

I’ll explain in less time than it takes to build this furniture.

 

Why isn’t Dad doing this for us like he usually does?

At our age, I think it’s time to be a little more independent!

Before thinking about buying, make a list of your upcoming projects for the next five years.

Are you thinking of continuing your studies?

Going on a trip? Buying a car?

Starting a business?

 

The idea is to establish your priorities.

Becoming a homeowner is gratifying, but if you have other projects that are more important to you, it’s okay to keep renting a place!

Renting offers more flexibility.

 

If your income is stable, predictable and your savings are good, start by identifying your needs.

 

How many bedrooms do you want?

Do you need parking?

And would you rather have a house or a condo?

Is it a shelf or a table?

 

Get to know the market and learn about the prices!

This will allow you to see if the properties that fit your criteria also fit your budget.

To buy something, you also need a down payment.

That’s a minimum of 5% of the price of the property.

Think about putting aside another 2 to 3% of the property’s value for other expenses like the inspection, the notary or the welcome tax.

Before asking for a mortgage loan, you can consult an advisor or use an online calculator to show you your monthly payments.

That will help you to better evaluate your budget

The important thing is to ensure that you are ready, financially and mentally, to become a homeowner, and then…just follow the steps.

 

Tada!

 

Nice!

 

Wasn’t it supposed to be a chair?

 

Yep!

- Are you wondering whether or not you’re ready to buy a house? I’ll explain in less time than it takes to build this furniture.

- Why isn’t Dad doing this for us like he usually does?

- At our age, I think it’s time to be a little more independent! Before thinking about buying, make a list of your upcoming projects for the next five years. Are you thinking of continuing your studies? Going on a trip? Buying a car? Starting a business? The idea is to establish your priorities. Becoming a homeowner is gratifying, but if you have other projects that are more important to you, it’s okay to keep renting a place! Renting offers more flexibility. If your income is stable, predictable and your savings are good, start by identifying your needs. How many bedrooms do you want? Do you need parking? And would you rather have a house or a condo?

- Is it a shelf or a table?

- Get to know the market and learn about the prices! This will allow you to see if the properties that fit your criteria also fit your budget. To buy something, you also need a down payment. That’s a minimum of 5% of the price of the property. Think about putting aside another 2 to 3% of the property’s value for other expenses like the inspection, the notary or the welcome tax. Before asking for a mortgage loan, you can consult an advisor or use an online calculator to show you your monthly payments. That will help you to better evaluate your budget. The important thing is to ensure that you are ready, financially and mentally, to become a homeowner, and then…just follow the steps.

- Tada!

- Nice! Wasn’t it supposed to be a chair?

- Yep!

- What are the basic questions that we we must answer to discover what's best for us.

- Yeah, there are some, you know that you can ask yourself and I will give you some of them, Simon. First, are you financially stable? OK. Does your budget allows you to absorb unforeseen events? Because like we said earlier, you can have a repair, you can have maintenance fees. So being an owner, you need to have a budget that is that, that has more room for these type of events. What about your employment situation? Are you looking for a new job? Is this new job that you will get be in another neighbourhood or even in another city? So that's a question that you have to ask yourself. Are you ready to spend time maintaining this house? That's a question to ask yourself. And your family situation will it change during the coming years, the coming months, are you going to have children or things like that? So that's all things that you have to consider. And are there expenses as well that you are absolutely not ready to let go of like you know travel, expensive cars, good restaurants. So that's all that, that's simple questions, but you have to ask them before making your decision to see which one fits you the most.

Legal disclaimer

Any reproduction, in whole or in part, is strictly prohibited without the prior written consent of National Bank of Canada.

The articles and information on this website are protected by the copyright laws in effect in Canada or other countries, as applicable. The copyrights on the articles and information belong to the National Bank of Canada or other persons. Any reproduction, redistribution, electronic communication, including indirectly via a hyperlink, in whole or in part, of these articles and information and any other use thereof that is not explicitly authorized is prohibited without the prior written consent of the copyright owner.

The contents of this website must not be interpreted, considered or used as if it were financial, legal, fiscal, or other advice. National Bank and its partners in contents will not be liable for any damages that you may incur from such use.

This article is provided by National Bank, its subsidiaries and group entities for information purposes only, and creates no legal or contractual obligation for National Bank, its subsidiaries and group entities. The details of this service offering and the conditions herein are subject to change.

The hyperlinks in this article may redirect to external websites not administered by National Bank. The Bank cannot be held liable for the content of external websites or any damages caused by their use.

Views expressed in this article are those of the person being interviewed. They do not necessarily reflect the opinions of National Bank or its subsidiaries. For financial or business advice, please consult your National Bank advisor, financial planner or an industry professional (e.g., accountant, tax specialist or lawyer).